Now this is all great and dandy, except I want my charging to be FAST.
Using my DMM I compared the resistance between pins comparing the HTC charger to the other chargers. I found that the data pins on the HTC charger were shorted and had infinite resistance to the power pins. However on my other charger there was ~13kohm resistance between the data pins and some high resistance between the data and power pins. hmm...
So I cracked open the 2A charger and found:

Ah hah! Some funky resistor/diode network going on here. Lets just get rid of all that and short the data pins:

I left the other resistor and diode because I was getting tired of de-soldering and they were no longer in the circuit anyway. (And second look the diode may be protection for the charging circuit so I am glad I left them!)

And now my phone detects it as a AC charger!
But it still only charges at 750mA according to battery monitor (HTC charger hit 850mA). I am stumped on that one. Though that is still quite a bit better then the 450mA it was charging at before.